Saved for later review

Archived Stories

Older Scarletude stories saved for later review.

4th and 1: Previous Questions5 previous questions · All situations, choices, and feedback in one place
Your spouse tells you that you never listen. You disagree and immediately feel defensive. You're convinced you're being unfairly criticized.

Your spouse tells you that you never listen. You disagree and immediately feel defensive. You're convinced you're being unfairly criticized.

What do you do?

  • Explain why the accusation isn't fair.
  • Apologize immediately to avoid an argument.
  • Ask for a specific example and listen before responding.
  • Say you're getting defensive and ask to revisit it after a short break.
See the mental-health lesson

The counselor’s perspective

Ask for a specific example and listen before responding.

A strong choice if you're calm enough to listen. It replaces a blanket accusation with something specific you can both discuss.

The bigger lesson

Feeling defensive is not the problem. What you decide to do with that feeling is what matters.

Anger is information, not instruction.

Thinking About Counseling?

You made a mistake at work that created extra problems for several coworkers. Nobody is yelling at you, but you know people are frustrated.

You made a mistake at work that created extra problems for several coworkers. Nobody is yelling at you, but you know people are frustrated.

Your first instinct is to explain why it happened and point out that other people contributed to the problem, too.

What’s your play?

  • A. Defend yourself immediately so nobody thinks the mistake was entirely your fault.

    There may be important context, but leading with a defense can make coworkers feel that you are avoiding responsibility. Start by acknowledging your part and its impact. You can discuss what else contributed once the immediate problem is being addressed.

  • B. Stay quiet and hope everyone forgets about it.

    Silence may feel easier, but it leaves your coworkers handling the consequences without knowing whether you will help. A brief acknowledgment and a specific offer to fix what you can are useful first steps.

  • C. Own your part, apologize, and focus on what you can do to help fix the problem.

    Taking responsibility does not mean accepting blame for everything. Name your part, acknowledge the extra work it caused, and offer a concrete next step. Following through on that step helps rebuild trust.

  • D. Get angry with yourself and spend the rest of the day replaying the mistake.

    Feeling bad does not fix the problem, and a mistake does not define your worth. Use that energy to make a repair, learn what you can do differently, and then give yourself permission to move forward.

Before you make your decision, ask yourself this question: What comes next? Be honest. Use logic. Emotions hate logic.

Thinking About Counseling?

Someone you love keeps hurting you, apologizing, and then doing the same thing again.

Someone you love keeps hurting you, apologizing, and then doing the same thing again.

You believe they care about you.

You also know the pattern is wearing you down.

What’s your play?

  • A. Keep forgiving them because everyone deserves another chance.

    Forgiveness is your choice, but it does not require accepting the same hurt repeatedly. Consider what changes you would need to see before offering another chance.

  • B. Walk away completely, even though you still love them.

    You can love someone and still decide that a relationship is hurting you. Stepping away is a valid choice. If leaving feels difficult or unsafe, consider support from someone you trust.

  • C. Stay, but stop expecting anything to change.

    Lowering your expectations may reduce disappointment, but it does not stop the hurt. Consider what staying is costing you and what you need to protect your well-being.

  • D. Set a firm boundary and let their response determine what happens next.

    A boundary describes what you will accept and what you will do if the pattern continues. Look for consistent changes in behavior, not just another apology. If setting a boundary feels unsafe, prioritize your safety and seek support.

Before you make your decision, ask yourself this question: What comes next? Be honest. Use logic. Emotions hate logic.

Thinking About Counseling?

Someone you trusted deeply has been lying to you for months.

Someone you trusted deeply has been lying to you for months.

You just found out.

You’re hurt, angry and not even sure what part of the relationship was real.

What’s your play?

  • A. Confront them immediately while everything is still raw.

    Your hurt deserves to be heard, but a conversation while everything is raw can be hard to navigate. Taking a pause can help you decide what you want to ask and what boundaries you need.

  • B. Walk away without giving them a chance to explain.

    You are allowed to step away, especially if you feel unsafe. You do not owe someone a conversation. If you are unsure what you want, give yourself time to make that decision.

  • C. Say nothing for now because you’re afraid of what the truth might mean.

    It is understandable to feel afraid of the answer. You can take time and seek support without pretending nothing happened. Consider what you need to know and what would help you feel ready.

  • D. Take some time, decide what you need to know, and then have the conversation when you can hear the answer without losing yourself in it.

    Taking time can help you stay connected to your own needs. Decide what you want to ask and what your boundaries are. Hearing their explanation does not obligate you to forgive them or continue the relationship.

Before you make your decision, ask yourself this question: What comes next? Be honest. Use logic. Emotions hate logic.

Thinking About Counseling?

Someone embarrasses you in front of other people.

Someone embarrasses you in front of other people.

What’s your play?

  • A. Fire back immediately

    Firing back may feel satisfying for a moment, but it can turn embarrassment into a bigger conflict. Give yourself time to decide what you actually want to say.

  • B. Stay quiet and stew about it

    Staying quiet can keep the moment from escalating, but replaying it may keep you upset. Once you are calm, decide whether a private conversation or a clear boundary would help.

  • C. Keep your cool until you calm down

    Keeping your cool gives you time to think instead of react. Once you calm down, you can decide whether to address what happened, set a boundary, or walk away.

  • D. Say something awful about their mother.

    Bringing their mother into it adds another insult without addressing what happened. Pause before saying something that could make the conflict worse or leave you with a regret.

Before you make your decision, ask yourself this question: What comes next? Be honest. Use logic. Emotions hate logic.

Thinking About Counseling?

  • Game Day Recap / Guardians vs. Rays · Game Day · 3 min read

    One Bad Inning Costs Guardians as Rays Even ALCS

    A three-run fourth inning costs Cleveland in a 3–1 loss to Tampa Bay. The ALCS is tied 1–1 as the Guardians return home to Progressive Field.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Support · 4 min read

    Roy Hall: Making It Possible for Somebody Else to Score

    Roy Hall’s blocked punt helped Ohio State beat Iowa on Oct. 18, 2003. His work on that play, and later with the DRIVEN Foundation, reminds us that helping someone else succeed matters.

  • Game Day Recap / Ohio State 45, Maryland 16 · Game Day · 4 min read

    A 29-Point Win With Plenty to Fix

    Ohio State beats Maryland 45-16 on a rainy homecoming afternoon, but eight penalties, two turnovers and shaky pass protection leave the Buckeyes plenty to fix before Indiana.

  • Mental Health Tip / Perspective · Support · 1 min read

    The Hawkeye Wave

    Perspective doesn’t erase our problems. But it can change the way we look at them.

  • Pop-Up Story / Confidence · Support · 3 min read

    Before Joe Cool, There Was Self-Doubt

    Before Joe Burrow became Joe Cool, he faced self-doubt at Ohio State. Billy Bruce reflects on self-criticism, confidence, and continuing to do the work.

  • Walk-On Writer Story / Joe Lapos · Support · 1 min introduction

    A Reason To Forgive

    A Scarletude introduction to Joe Lapos's reflection on brokenness, judgment, and forgiveness. Read the original story at JoeSportico.

  • Mental Health Game Notes / Progress · Support · 2 min read

    The 19-Play Drive

    Sometimes improving our mental health looks less like a highlight play and more like keeping a 19-play drive alive.

  • Game Day Feature / Patience · Game Day · 3 min read

    Collin Dixon: The Value of Patience

    Tallmadge native and Illinois receiver Collin Dixon returns to Ohio after years of patient work made him one of the Illini's biggest offensive weapons.

  • Archived Game Day Recap / Ohio State 59, Kent State 3 · Game Day · 3 min read

    Hair of the Dog: Buckeyes Bite Back Against Kent State

    Jeremiah Smith became Ohio State’s all-time receiving leader as the Buckeyes shook off their Texas hangover with a 59-3 rout of Kent State.

  • Archived Mental Health Game Notes / Moving Forward · Support · 2 min read

    Yesterday Doesn’t Get Today

    Learn from what happened, fix what needs fixed, then go play the next game.

  • Archived Game Day Recap / Ohio State 59, Kent State 3 · Game Day · 5 min read

    No Texas Hangover

    Ohio State answered its loss at Texas with a 59-3 rout of Kent State as Jeremiah Smith made history and the Buckeye defense dominated.

  • Game Day Feature / Resilience · Game Day · 5 min read

    The Hardest Part Wasn’t the Knee

    Kent State quarterback Dru DeShields tore the same ACL three times. His return to football became a story of resilience, belief and helping others recover.

  • Game Day Recap / Texas 24, Ohio State 23 · Game Day · 4 min read

    A Tale of Two Halves

    Ohio State controlled the first half in Austin, then watched a 20-point lead disappear in a stunning 24-23 loss to Texas.

  • Whatever Happened To...? / Athlete Identity · Recovery · External feature

    Redgie Arden: What Matters Most

    Former Ohio State tight end Redgie Arden reflects on football’s pitfalls, keeping priorities in order and life after the spotlight.

  • Archived Mental Health Game Notes / Reset · Support · 3 min read

    The Next Play Doesn’t Know You Screwed Up the Last One

    It also doesn’t know you succeeded. Billy Bruce reflects on how Texas moved past early mistakes while Ohio State learned that previous success cannot decide the next play.

  • Archived Game Day Feature / Quarterback Focus · Game Day · 4 min read

    Julian Sayin Enters 2026 Ready to Lead Ohio State

    An archived feature on Ohio State quarterback Julian Sayin entering the 2026 season ready to turn the lessons of his first year as a starter into a championship run.

  • Self-Worth / Quiet Impact · Recovery · 3 min read

    Butler By'not'e's 49-Yard Moment

    One opening. Forty-nine yards. One Buckeye moment worth remembering from Ohio State's 1993 win over Washington.

  • Playoff / Redemption · Recovery · 4 min read

    Jack Sawyer

    Jack Sawyer traces the hometown Buckeye captain's journey from a painful rivalry loss to his legendary 83-yard touchdown against Texas in the College Football Playoff.

  • Mental Health Companion · Anxiety · 2 min read

    Stay in Your Lane

    Your value doesn't depend on somebody else's spotlight. Be ready for your By'not'e opening.

  • Mental Health Companion · Recovery · 2 min read

    Jack Sawyer Mental Health Comp

    Jack Sawyer Mental Health Comp explores how one terrible moment does not define a life and how moving forward can create an entirely different ending.

  • Fear Is A Liar · Recovery · 7 min read

    Overcomers

    Overcomers tells the Ohio State story of Evan Spencer, whose unselfish blocking, leadership, and role in a championship reveal why impact is bigger than statistics.

  • Fear Is A Liar Overall Lesson · Anxiety · 5 min read

    The Overcomer's Mindset

    The Overcomer's Mindset explores mental health, comparison, and self-worth through Evan Spencer's Ohio State role beyond the stat sheet and the quiet contributions that help a team succeed.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 4 min read

    Jermale Hines: Finding Another Way to Win

    Jermale Hines’ pick-six helped Ohio State beat Wisconsin on Oct. 10, 2009. When the original plan wasn’t working, the Buckeyes found another way, a reminder to think in terms of problems and solutions.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 3 min read

    Percy King’s Masterstroke

    On Oct. 3, 1998, Percy King blocked a Penn State punt for Ohio State. Years later, the former Buckeye found a new calling as an artist whose work appeared in the Columbus Museum of Art.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 4 min read

    Antonio Smith Took His Chance 55 Yards to the House

    In Ohio State's 2006 win over Penn State, former walk-on Antonio Smith returned his first college interception for a touchdown. His road there was years in the making.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 4 min read

    Butler By'not'e Breaks Out

    Butler By'not'e sparked Ohio State against Pittsburgh in 1993 and showed why being ready for one defining opportunity still matters.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 4 min read

    The Ryan Hamby Game

    The Ryan Hamby Game revisits Ohio State's 2005 loss to eventual national champion Texas and asks fans to remember the person behind a painful mistake.

  • This Week in Buckeyes History · Recovery · 6 min read

    The Virginia Tech Loss

    The Virginia Tech Loss revisits Ohio State's 2014 upset, the lessons it exposed, and the championship response that followed for the Buckeyes.

Travis Bazzana Takes Questions

Travis Bazzana answers questions in a video shared by Nick Toombs.

Video: Nick Toombs / Facebook. Watch on Facebook

Return to Scarletude stories